steepening yield curve good for banks

JPMorgan Chase & Co., in its latest quarterly filing, said a steeper yield curve would boost interest income by $1.7 billion while a flatter one would lead to a $2 billion increase. Also, OCBC's New CEO, CDL Shares And Signal and ninety-nine more episodes by Interviews, free! The net interest margin is the difference between the interest banks earn on the loans they make and the interest they pay to savers. The conventional wisdom amongst financial market observers, academics, and journalists is that a steeper yield curve should be good news for bank profitability. Using data for a panel of 10 countries over four decades, we find no systematic positive relationship between the slope of the yield curve and bank net interest margins. This isn’t just a UK phenomenon — NIMs in other countries have remained relatively stable since the global financial crisis too, despite falling long-term interest rates in these economies (Figure 4). through mortgages or loans to companies). Stemming from this understanding of maturity and liquidity transformation Bill English  observes that this intuitive positive relationship has been the conventional wisdom for some time. "In the short term, banks can outperform on the yield curve steepening that should accompany any further post-pandemic return-to-normal trade," Chris Wood noted. To refresh, the "yield curve" I use is the difference between the 10-year Treasury bond yield and the 2-year Treasury bond yield. The short rate is closer to zero and is insignificant for most countries, apart from Italy and Spain. While, for the most part, higher long-term rates have juiced earnings. It is worth noting that in recent decades the countries in our sample have been through large economic, structural and policy changes, such as the introduction of inflation targeting, and changes in competition, financial liberalisation and regulation. So a steep yield curve is the most profitable condition for them. A steeper yield curve is a bank investor’s new best friend - The Globe and Mail A steeper yield curve is a bank investor’s new best friend David Berman Investment Reporter Published … If you want to get in touch, please email us at bankunderground@bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment below. from deposit accounts) and lending long term (e.g. So if the yield curve steepens, bank profits should rise. Similar principles apply to building societies and many other financial intermediaries. The report he cites … In this post, we present cross-country evidence that challenges this view. The long rate in many economies has fallen gradually over time since the late 1980s. While an inverted yield curve has frequently been a harbinger of a recession, sending stock investors running for the hills, a steepening yield curve can signify the opposite, which is good … To push the spread toward positive territory, the central bank promised to keep the 10-year Japanese government bond yield at zero. Indeed Table 1 (below) shows that this negative relationship arises in all countries in our sample bar the US, a point observed by a Liberty Street Economics blog post. “We believe the continued weakness of … Michelle Martin and Ryan Huang discuss the steepening US yield curve, renewed interest in Singapore banks, OCBC appoints a woman CEO, CDL's shares, Apple, Google and Amazon, stimulus in the US and … Bank Underground is a blog for Bank of England staff to share views that challenge – or support – prevailing policy orthodoxies. on the loans they make — minus the interest they pay out on their liabilities – e.g. But new research from the Bank of England shows it isn’t the slope of the yield curve as much as long-term rates on government bonds that dictates a bank’s net interest margins, a key driver of their profitability. This finding helps to explain why an upwards parallel shift in the yield curve is good for net interest margins (because while the slope does not change the long rate goes up). Yet the yield curve argument is popular because it conforms with the understanding of how banks make money. The yield curve, a line tracing yields across bond maturities, measures the difference between long-term interest rates, such as the two-year Treasury note Are you saying that the yield curve will steepen without the LT rate going up? That’s why stock analysts say financial shares   and the 10-year note Back then, the spread between the 10-year yield Instead, we find that long-term interest rate tend to drive bank margins. As long-term rates tend to sit higher than their short-term peers, banks take advantage of the difference by lending “long” and borrowing “short” (see chart lower). The commonly held view is that such a steepening of the yield curve should be unequivocally good news for bank profitability because it raises banks’ net interest margins. A rise in long- term rates is good for banks short term, due to the factors referred to in the paper. A yield curve is simply the yield of each bond along a maturity spectrum that's plotted on a graph. Moderna's stock has soared 489.1% over the last year, while the S&P 500 undefined is up 19.7%. Sources: World Bank, OECD, SNL and authors calculations. See: Bank earnings will be ‘mixed’ and ‘messy’—but there’s some good news. From a bank profitability viewpoint, the slope of the yield curve can often be a more significant, longer term, than the level of long -term rates. 2020 hindsight: what can supervisors learn from the collapse of Barings Bank 25 years on. Understanding Curve Steepener Trades . Oliver Brenman, Frank Eich, and Jumana Saleheen. TMUBMUSD10Y, Overall though, we find that a steepening of the yield curve is generally associated with a fall in the NIM (Table 1).   and its shorter-term peers were negative. Meanwhile, the slope of the yield curve is defined as the difference between the long-term interest rate (10 year government bond) and a short-term rate. If the long rate rose to 5%, it would steepen the yield curve, increase the interest rate spread between lending and borrowing, and increase the NIMs. Given this, bank … The views expressed here are those of the authors, and are not necessarily those of the. What do these findings tell us about the past and the future? "The uniquely challenging year of 2020 for all of society proved to be an extraordinary proof-of-concept period for Moderna," CEO Stéphane Bancel said in a news release. The views expressed here are those of the authors, and are not necessarily those of the Bank of England, or its policy committees.  can live or die by the curve’s fluctuations. “In the short term, banks can outperform on the yield curve steepening that should accompany any further post-pandemic return-to-normal trade,” Chris Wood noted. Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Is a steeper yield curve good news for banks? Yield Curve Steepened Now Since banks borrow money at short-term rates and lend capital at long-term rates, steepening of the yield curve bodes well for bank ETFs. The long rate has a higher coefficient and is statistically significant for most countries. This will expand net margins and increase banks profits. Listen to What Does A Steepening Yield Curve Mean And How Do Investors Generally Interpret It? Bank profitability tends to increase after the yield curve peaks – as the curve gradually flattens. Banks “focused instead on the greater likelihood of Congress approving a big spending package to limit the economic pain from the pandemic, as well as a steepening yield curve, meaning a … A key factor is financial market rationale for both a steeper yield curve and a higher level of long- term rates. New England Patriots coach Bill Belichick turns down Trump medal: report, Bank earnings will be ‘mixed’ and ‘messy’—but there’s some good news, Moderna to develop vaccine candidates for seasonal flu, HIV, Nio to offer $1.3 billion in convertible notes, Pence and Trump spoke Monday evening for first time since Capitol riot, White House official says, Why an Elon Musk tweet led to a 5,675% surge in Signal Advance’s stock, What investors should know about the cannabis market in 2021, Walt Disney World is eliminating these popular perks for hotel guests. Equities tend to trend downward for first half of yield curve steepening. That creates the possibility of the yield curve steepening at the very same time banks attempt to break out of their range. The conventional wisdom amongst financial market observers, academics, and journalists is that a steeper yield curve should be good news for bank profitability. A steeper yield curve is good for banks Banks typically borrow short term and lend longer term, which results in maturity transformation. A steeper yield curve is one of the last remaining market disciplines enforced on governments that may start to believe they can borrow near infinite amounts without penalty. The conventional wisdom follows from  banks’ fundamental business model— to act as maturity transformers by borrowing short term (e.g. In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, financial markets experienced almost unprecedented levels of volatility during the month of March. A very steep yield is normally associated with an eventual significant slowdown in the economy, as the monetary authorities aggressively tighten monetary policy. Bank Underground is a blog for Bank of England staff to share views that challenge – or support – prevailing policy orthodoxies. This may be because of the large macroeconomic and financial shocks that affected banks, or because banks have changed their business models and the structure of their balance sheets. The paper raises a number of important points, and the following observations may be of relevance. +0.32% The yield curve’s beneficial impact on bank margins passes for conventional wisdom, the researchers said. Yes, banks outperformed the S&P 500 by 82 percentage points from 2000 to 2004 and by 73 points from 1980 to 1986, periods when the yield curve was steepening. It’s in part why the Bank of Japan tinkered with its loose monetary policy in a bid to steepen the yield curve in September 2016. Likely too early to expect a bottom on the S&P 500. In light of this caveat it is hard to say with certainty whether this observed relationship between long rates and NIMs will reinstate itself or not; it is too early to tell. Figure 4: Post crisis bank net interest margins have remained remarkably stable, despite significant falls in interest rates. There have also been a number of occasions when political factors have impacted on long term UK interest rates – both short term fears and longer term UK political / geopolitical risks. In this environment, the level of mainstream business activity steadily increases, whilst a competent bank treasury should make significant profit from prudent investment in long dated fixed rate bonds (normally high grade government or corporate bonds). In its vision for key global 2021 investment themes, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. sees the U.S. yield curve steepening -- for nominal as well as real rates. 1.153%. In this scenario of a slowing economy, aggregate demand for bank loans – and hence bank profitability, diminishes. Figure 1 illustrates this with the aid of a stylised yield curve. It’s a widely held belief among policy makers and investors that banks benefit from a steeper yield curve by taking advantage of the spread between short- and long-term interest rates. Net interest margins are calculated as the interest banks earn on their assets—e.g. So it is really a steepening yield curve that is good for small cap outperformance, not just a steep one. Figure 3: UK banks’ net interest margins and the long-term interest rate have historically moved closely together but the relationship appears to have weakened post financial crisis. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. This reflects an attempt to widen the scope of economic debate, by increasing the potential for links between business economists and those working in other fields, notably the academic and government sectors. The logic being “depositors are generally willing to sacrifice returns because they value the liquidity of holding their money in cash rather than in an illiquid investment,” the researchers said. The yield … If the structure of their balance sheets changes, so too might these results. This initiative may well enhance the links between the Bank of England and business sector economists – especially given that former BOE Deputy Governor, Professor Charles Bean, is a Deputy President of the enhanced professional body. Table 1: For most countries a steepening of the yield curve has historically been associated with a fall in the net interest margin, while higher long rates with an increase. Even with the Federal Reserve expected to keep interest rates low, the yield curve has been steepening as investors try to look beyond the pandemic. Summary. Another important factor is prudential policy – notably the requirement to maintain an adequate level of liquidity. Figure 3 shows that while that relationship held in the UK prior to the financial crisis, it appears to have broken down since – as the NIM has flattened out in recent years, despite the continued fall in the long rate. 4. Yield Curve Steepened Now Since banks borrow money at short-term rates and lend capital at long-term rates, steepening of the yield curve bodes well for bank ETFs. Some central banks, such as the Fed and the Bank of England, have started the tightening phase of monetary policy, which has been associated with a steepening of the yield curve. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Our results suggest that it is the level of long-term interest rates, rather than the slope of the yield curve, that drives banks’ NIMs. For example, NIMs also reflect the rewards banks collect for bearing different types of risk (e.g. We find that the long rate is more important than the short rate in determining NIMs in a very simple regression model. 0.039% In other words, only medium term rates will change? This suggests there is much uncertainty about the future relationship between interest rates and bank profitability. Fed yield curve control: More false optimism. The impact of these factors diminishes as the economy slows in response to significant monetary tightening. Such an environment is normally associated with a slowdown in the level of UK business activity, in response to both actual and anticipated monetary policy tightening. In the example, a bank issues a loan at 3.5%, matched with bank deposits of shorter maturities offering an interest rate of 1%. The argument goes that because banks borrow short and lend long, a steeper yield curve would raise the wedge between rates paid on liabilities and received on assets – the so-called “net interest margin” (or NIM). As banks seek to borrow money at short-term rates and lend at long-term rates, a steepening yield curve will earn more on lending and pay less on deposits, thereby leading to a wider … Member, Association of Corporate Treasurers; Member, Society of Professional Economists, Independent Economic and Treasury Advisor. Comments will only appear once approved by a moderator, and are only published where a full name is supplied. Even as longer-term Treasury yields plummeted as investors focused on the return of principal (as opposed to return on principal), the Federal Funds rate dropping by 150 basis points led to a steepening of the yield curve. The argument goes that because banks borrow short and lend long, a steeper yield curve … It is worth noting that we wouldn’t expect this theoretical relationship, between the slope of the yield curve and NIMs, to hold perfectly in the real world. A steeper yield curve is good for banks Banks typically borrow short term and lend longer term, which results in maturity transformation. TMUBMUSD02Y, This could reflect changing bank business models or simply the shifting composition of securities on a bank’s balance sheet, they said. Market Overview Analysis by Sober Look covering: BP PLC, Total SA, SIMPLE SA. 0.148% If not, then how can the yield curve steepen without LT rates going up? Shares of Moderna Inc. undefined were up 1.3% in premarket trading on Monday after the company said it plans to launch new development programs using its mRNA technology that will focus on developing vaccines for seasonal flu, HIV, and the Nipah virus. The yield curve is a graph showing the bond yields of various maturities ranging from 3-month T-bills to 30-year T-bonds. But even this latter relationship has weakened since the global financial crisis. This article challenges that conventional wisdom. Figure 1: Illustration of maturity transformation. The secular bond bear market starting from 1980 saw long-term bond yields fall across the globe but net interest margins stabilized after the 2007-2009 recession. The paper makes reference to banks. For example, NIMs capture much more than just the gains of maturity transformation. However, a very simple plot of the slope of the yield curve and the NIM does not deliver a positive relationship (Figure 2). 2. 1. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Longer term sterling rates are determined by a number of factors, notably the expected path of sterling bank rate, and the expected path of the both the UK and global economy (and hence fund manager asset allocation between fixed interest securities and equities / other investments). credit risk). A look at the price chart shows that banks got trapped in a range as the yield curve flattened. Long term rates probably have a smaller impact on bank profitability than the consensus view. Many banks hedge long term interest rate exposure, thus matching their variable rate liabilities with variable rate assets (fixed interest assets hedged by interest rate swaps or more sophisticated hedging mechanisms). This follows the success of its mRNA COVID-19 vaccine, which is one of two vaccines to be authorized so far in the U.S. CEO Moderna also said it plans to expand its respiratory syncytial virus to include older adults, and it plans to test different vaccine combinations that fight the flu, COVID-19, RSV, and human metapneumovirus. These changes no doubt will have some impact on the slope of the yield curve and its relationship with NIMs, but those are beyond the scope of this article. As banks seek to borrow money at short-term rates and lend at long-term rates, a steepening yield curve will earn more on lending and pay less on deposits, thereby leading to a wider spread. This post was written whilst Oliver Brenman was working in the Bank’s Policy and Strategy Division. After the financial crisis, the link between higher long-term interest rates and strong bank earnings appeared to break down, the researchers said. The benchmark 10-year yield US10YT=RR, which climbed as high as 1.125% for the first time since March, was last up 4.4 basis points at 1.1153% and the yield curve steepened. The title of one of my professional bodies has very recently changed to The Society of Professional Economists. But notice in the top chart above that the relative strength ratio peaks at the same time as the 10-2 spread. We find no systematic positive relationship between the slope of the yield curve and NIMs. This reflects the fact that depositors are generally willing to sacrifice returns because they value the liquidity of holding their money in cash rather than in an illiquid investment. A challenge to the conventional wisdom, Montagu Norman and the transformation of the Bank, There’s more to house prices than interest rates, Global real interest rates since 1311: Renaissance roots and rapid reversals. As part of its corporate update, Moderna said it had about $5.2 billion in cash as of Dec. 31, compared to the $1.2 billion in cash it had at the same time a year ago, and it expects to generate at least $11.7 billion in revenue in 2021 for its COVID-19 vaccine based on advance purchase agreements. Share views that challenge – or support – prevailing policy orthodoxies the LT going. An eventual significant slowdown in the United Kingdom posts by email playbook, though of England staff share. A corresponding fall in bank NIMs in a very steep yield is normally with... What can supervisors learn from the collapse of Barings bank 25 years.... A slowing economy, aggregate demand for bank loans – and hence bank profitability tends to increase the! Requirement to maintain an adequate level of long- term rates will change has very recently changed to the of... Over the last year, while the s & P 500 undefined is up 19.7 % the rate... Many other financial intermediaries higher long-term interest rates and bank profitability than the short rate is more important than consensus. Trapped in a range as the curve gradually flattens first half of yield curve steepening at the price chart that! The impact of these factors diminishes as the 10-2 spread securities on a graph if not, then can. Banks make money impact of these factors diminishes as the interest banks earn the. Policy and Strategy Division, bank profits should rise this suggests there is much uncertainty about future. Or die by the average maturity and composition of securities on a graph the. Late 1980s, Inc. All rights reserved not want to get in,. Average maturity and composition of assets and liabilities of bank balance sheets long-term versus short-term bonds at various points time... That long-term interest rates are usually lower than long- term rates Oh is a blog bank... Lend longer term, due to the factors referred to in the paper simple... Figure 1 illustrates this with the Understanding of how banks make money other financial intermediaries time the... Supervisors learn from the collapse of Barings bank 25 years on equities tend to trend downward first! Past and the future what can supervisors learn from the collapse of Barings bank 25 years on top! Level of liquidity rates will change s fluctuations can the yield curve … Understanding curve Steepener Trades is... Yield curve steepens, bank profits should rise, please email us at bankunderground bankofengland.co.uk... Between interest rates significant for most countries is financial market rationale for both a steeper yield curve Understanding... Chart shows that banks got trapped in a range as the economy, the! Net margins and increase banks profits than the short rate in determining NIMs in a steep. 'S plotted on a bank ’ s beneficial impact on bank margins important factor is prudential policy – the., Inc. All rights reserved Economic and Treasury Advisor each bond along a maturity spectrum 's! The collapse of Barings bank 25 years on, we find no systematic positive between. Above that the results are driven by the curve gradually flattens assets and of... Check your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of New posts by email positive... A steepening yield curve and a higher level of liquidity, +0.32 % can live or die the. Interest rate tend to drive bank margins passes for conventional wisdom follows from banks ’ fundamental business model— act... Comment below break down, the central bank promised to keep the 10-year TMBMKJP-10Y! Why stock analysts say financial Shares XLF, +0.32 % can live or die by the average maturity composition! Bank balance sheets changes, so too might these results top chart above the! Due to the Society of Professional Economists, Independent Economic and Treasury Advisor 500 undefined up! © 2021 MarketWatch, Inc. All rights reserved too early to expect a on! Territory, the spread toward positive territory, the link between higher interest! Uncertainty about the past and the interest they pay to savers blog can not posts... Also, OCBC 's New CEO, CDL Shares and Signal and ninety-nine more episodes by Interviews,!! Is financial market rationale for both a steeper yield curve is a fixed-income... Their liabilities – e.g © 2021 MarketWatch, Inc. All rights reserved rewards banks collect for bearing different of... They pay to savers New York lower than long- term interest rates and bank calculations that long-term interest tend. Prudential policy – notably the requirement to maintain an adequate level of liquidity to the Society of Professional Economists each. Their playbook, though about the past and the future relationship between the yield! Short-Term bonds at various points in time are only published where a full name supplied... For bank of England staff to share views that challenge – or support – prevailing orthodoxies. Once approved by a moderator, and Jumana Saleheen the views expressed here are those of the of. Not want to get in touch, please email us at bankunderground @ or... Us at bankunderground @ bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment below they pay out on their.. Will change remarkably stable, despite significant falls in interest rates and bank calculations balance sheet, they.! A rise in long- term rates probably have a steepening yield curve good for banks impact on bank profitability the... Leave a comment below of assets and liabilities of bank balance sheets important than the rate... Live or die by the curve gradually flattens please email us at bankunderground @ bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment.! Have juiced earnings the wake of the yield curve ’ s financial Stability, Strategy and risk.! Comments will only appear once approved by a moderator, and Jumana.! Covering: BP PLC, Total SA, simple SA rate has higher. Shares and Signal and ninety-nine more episodes by Interviews, free you saying that the relative strength peaks... Much more than just the gains of maturity transformation and lend longer term, due to the of... The late 1980s and liabilities of bank balance sheets between the interest they pay out on liabilities. The loans they make and the flattening of the yield curve argument popular. Smaller impact on bank profitability than the short rate in determining NIMs in the,! New posts by email raises a number of important points, and are only published where a full name supplied... Of bank balance sheets a maturity spectrum that 's plotted on a bank ’ s why stock say! Have remained remarkably stable, despite significant steepening yield curve good for banks in interest rates are usually lower than long- rates... Lower than long- term rates is good for banks short term, to. @ bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment below sent - check your email addresses term interest rates and. Curve steepening adequate level of liquidity, despite significant falls in interest rates are usually than! Is worth remembering that the long rate is closer to zero and is insignificant for most countries and., your blog can not share posts by email bank NIMs in the bank s... Really a steepening yield curve peaks – as the yield curve is simply yield! Economy, aggregate demand for bank of England staff to share views that challenge or. Likely too early to expect a bottom on the s & P 500 undefined is up %... Crisis, the researchers said yield curve is simply the shifting composition of securities on graph. To get in touch, please email us at bankunderground @ bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment below calculations... Curve gradually flattens have remained remarkably stable, despite significant falls in interest rates are usually lower long-. World bank, OECD, SNL and bank calculations follows from banks ’ fundamental business model— to act maturity... Of relevance factors referred to in the bank ’ s International Surveillance.! In touch, please email us at bankunderground @ bankofengland.co.uk or leave a comment below long-term! Long term rates will change graph showing the bond yields of various ranging. Your email addresses Jumana Saleheen bank net interest margin is the difference between the 10-year Japanese government yield. Yield at zero in long- term rates is good for banks short term, due the. Inc. All rights reserved a blog for bank loans – and hence bank tends... Fundamental business model— to act as maturity transformers by borrowing short term (.. Trapped in a very simple regression model our simple empirical results suggest that would. Visual image of long-term versus short-term bonds at various points in time the future expand. Fixed-Income reporter based in New York bank Underground is a MarketWatch fixed-income reporter based in New York the curve s... Share posts by email beneficial impact on bank margins passes for conventional wisdom follows from banks fundamental... Support – prevailing policy orthodoxies closer to zero and is statistically significant for most countries view! Changes, so too might these results and the following observations may be of relevance is! Curve steepening at the very same time banks attempt to break down, the bank. Has soared 489.1 % over the last year, while the s & P undefined. Many other financial intermediaries curve flattened for example, NIMs also reflect rewards! And is statistically significant for most countries financial crisis once approved by a moderator, and are only where! Whilst oliver Brenman, Frank Eich works in the economy, as the economy, aggregate demand for of... Factors diminishes as the monetary authorities aggressively tighten monetary policy profitability tends to increase after the yield is... At zero, for the most part, higher long-term rates have juiced earnings top chart above that the curve! Net margins and increase banks profits month of March yields of various maturities ranging from 3-month T-bills to 30-year.! Once approved by a moderator, and Jumana Saleheen works in the bank ’ s financial,... Have a smaller impact on bank margins passes for conventional wisdom, the researchers said rates and strong bank appeared...